Women’s Ordination Question Goes to GC Session
Delegates vote after six hours of presentations and discussion in a “gracious” atmosphere punctuated with 17 prayers.
Annual Council delegates agreed to ask the General Conference session next year whether each division may decide for itself whether to ordain women, and many expressed hope that a final decision on the matter will allow the church to focus more fully on its mission of proclaiming Jesus’ soon coming.
The daylong session unfolded calmly, and session chair Michael L. Ryan, a vice president of the General Conference, sought to keep a neutral atmosphere, even mildly chiding delegates for applauding a speech by former General Conference president Jan Paulsen.
After six hours of presentations and discussion on Tuesday, the delegates of the Annual Council, a major church business meeting, overwhelmingly approved a request to put a question on the matter before the 2015 General Conference session. If approved, the action would authorize each of the 13 divisions of the Seventh-day Adventist Church to ordain women in its territory if it desired.
The delegates endorsed the request and an accompanying three-page statement — both drafted by General Conference and division leaders — in a 243-44 vote with three abstentions.
“I want to thank you for the gracious spirit with which you have conducted this meeting,” Ted N.C. Wilson, president of the General Conference, said moments after the results of the electronic secret ballot flashed up on the screen. “We hope for this at the General Conference session.”
Earlier Wilson promised to adhere to whatever decision the General Conference session made on women’s ordination.
"I pledge to you I will follow what the General Conference session votes,” he said. “I ask you to do the same."
The question that will be posed to the delegates at the General Conference session next July is: “After your prayerful study on ordination from the Bible, the writings of Ellen G. White, and the reports of the study commissions, and; after your careful consideration of what is best for the church and the fulfillment of its mission, is it acceptable for division executive committees, as they may deem it appropriate in their territories, to make provision for the ordination of women to the gospel ministry? Yes or No.”
Read full document (PDF)
Calls for a "Fix" and Unity
For the discussion, which started after lunch, delegates were urged to focus on the matter of the request itself rather than the larger issue of ordaining women to ministry. Forty-one delegates took turns speaking at four microphones placed in the aisles of the main auditorium of the world church headquarters in Silver Spring, Maryland. Many supported the motion, and a few took the opportunity to voice their stance on women’s ordination.
Several delegates expressed disappointment that women’s ordination, which was considered in several forms but turned down at two General Conference sessions in 1990 and 1995, had returned to the forefront. They said that spending more time on the issue risked diverting attention from the church’s main mission.
G.T. Ng, executive secretary of the General Conference, took to the floor late in the afternoon to say that in the past 24 hours, including the time while church leaders had been discussing ordination, 360,000 babies had been born and 151,000 people had died around the world.
“What are we doing about them?” he said. “That is why we must get over our fixation with this issue and get on with the mission of the church.”
Ryan, former director for the church’s Global Mission and a longtime missionary in Asia, frowned when some delegates applauded and said he shouldn’t comment on Ng’s call for mission. But then he added: “I know that we all have that as our primary burden.”
Paulsen, 79, who served as General Conference president from 1999 to 2010, drew sustained applause with a passionate appeal for a decision about women’s ordination. Expressing regret that he had never tackled the issue as president, he warned that the church faced "irreparable damage" if the question was not settled at the General Conference session, which will be held in San Antonio, Texas.
"We don't have time beyond San Antonio, so please fix this one," Paulsen said.
Ryan allowed the clapping to continue for a short time before gently reproving the crowd. Ryan said the injection of emotion into the discussion could encourage other people to respond more passionately. "Listen to the statements without a personal expression," he said.
Ron Halvorsen Jr., president of the church’s Ohio Conference, urged church leaders to do whatever possible to restrain emotional rhetoric sometimes clouding the discussion. He suggested that heated language from hard-line elements on both sides of the issue was hurting the church.
Guillermo Biaggi, president of the Euro-Asia Division, which includes many of the former Soviet republics, reminded delegates that the Soviet authorities had divided the church, sending part of it underground, but General Conference leadership had helped reunite it and the church is now stronger than ever.
“We hope that the decision that is reached will honor the sacrifice of our pioneers,” he said.
Unity was also highlighted by Peter Landless, director of the Health Ministries department and the presenter of the morning devotional. At the worship service Landless told how he had once misspelled the word “united” as “untied” and realized: "If we are not united, we are untied."
Other delegates voiced confidence that the church would remain united no matter what decision was made on ordination, and Wilson, in closing remarks at the end of the session, read Jesus’ prayer for unity from John 17:20, 21: “I do not pray for these alone, but also for those who will believe in Me through their word; that they all may be one, as You, Father, are in Me, and I in You; that the world may believe that You sent Me” (NKJV).
Request to Amend the Motion
Only one proposal to amend the request was formally considered during Tuesday’s proceedings, and it was denied in a 184-96 vote. The proposal, made by David Trim, the General Conference’s chief archivist, was critiqued by three delegates who took to the floor to say it would tilt the question to be put to the 2015 General Conference session in favor of Position No. 3, one of three positions on women’s ordination that emerged from a two-year, church-commissioned study of the issue. Trim helped draft Position No. 3.
Throughout the discussion, a half-dozen General Conference and division leaders emphasized the neutrality of the request to the General Conference session and the amount of prayer that had gone into drafting it.
Heather-Dawn Small, director of the Women's Ministries department at the General Conference, urged that the Annual Council itself take a vote on the question before it rather than only sending the question to the General Conference session.
David Weigley, president of the Columbia Union Conference, offered an amendment that would have allowed the delegates at Tuesday’s meeting to express their own preference about allowing divisions to resolve the thorny issue. Ryan, chair of the meeting, refused the amendment as ‘hostile” to the neutral intent of the question under consideration, and a parliamentarian, responsible for making sure that the proceedings followed the rules, indicated that Ryan was within his rights to do so.
The morning portion of the session was largely devoted to a review of the work of the Theology of Ordination Study Committee and 20-minute presentations of the three positions that emerged. The three presenters were Clinton Wahlen, associate director of the church’s Biblical Research Institute, for Position No. 1; Walla Walla University theology professor Carl Cosaert for Position No. 2; and Seventh-day Adventist Theological Seminary professor Nicholas Miller for Position No. 3.
Before the presentations, delegates strongly endorsed the report prepared by the Theology of Ordination Study Committee, or TOSC, in a 280-3 vote, with four abstentions.
Several delegates later asked General Conference leadership to make sure that the General Conference session was thoroughly aware of the three positions. Ryan and Wilson offered assurances that next year’s session delegates would receive the necessary materials.
Wilson, in an interview after the Tuesday’s vote, appealed to church members and especially delegates to the General Conference session to prayerfully study for themselves what the Bible, the writings of Adventist Church co-founder Ellen G. White, and TOSC have to say about ordination before the session.
“This is a sacred responsibility placed on their shoulders because the Spirit of Prophecy says that the General Conference in session has high authority,” Wilson said.
The session — which opened at 8 a.m. and ended at 5:38 p.m. and included a two-hour lunch break and a couple short presentations unrelated to ordination — halted proceedings multiple times for prayer. Seventeen one-on-one and group prayers were offered.
Expectations were high ahead of the session. In-house television feeds and extra seating were prepared in the cafeteria and an upstairs meeting room for the expected overflow crowd. Headquarters employees had been advised that they should watch the proceedings from the alternate viewing sites and leave auditorium space for official delegates and attendees. Building security guards dotted the corridors and stood near the exit of the main auditorium. Longtime General Conference employees said they had never seen such tight security.
Wilson even teased about it in his opening remarks. He said the General Conference wanted to conduct the ordination discussion in an open and transparent atmosphere and, like every year, anyone was welcome to attend Annual Council.
“As long as you can get past security, you’re welcome to come in,” he said to audience laughter.
The main auditorium was packed for the morning session, but only modest numbers sat in the overflow rooms. When the session reconvened after lunch, the extra security guards had disappeared, and a few open seats appeared in the back of the auditorium.
Contact news editor Andrew McChesney at firstname.lastname@example.org. Twitter: @ARMcChesney
Adventist Review, Sept. 23, 2014: "Adventists Urged to Study Women’s Ordination for Themselves"