BY BILL KNOTT
HE VIEW FROM THE HOUSE ON MEEKER HILL ROAD STARTLES YOU at
first. It's not what you expected from so comfortable a place.
The verdant hills through which Interstate 81 threads south
of Syracuse, New York, roll up against each other with easy familiarity. None
are high or craggy: all bear the impress of the dairy farms and orchards that
have been the backbone of this region for more than 200 years. It is a landscape
of solidity and strength, not surprises.
But when Duane Cady looks east or west, and especially north,
he can see what few of his neighbors ever see--miles and miles of green hills
and mowed fields stretching toward the broad basin in which three quarters of
a million people live and work. Beyond, as far as the east is from the west,
the waters of Lake Ontario draw a thin gray pencil line on the horizon.
That breadth of view, a taste for far horizons, somehow matches
the man who sits quietly beside the piano in his living room, dissecting the
challenges and crises of health care in the United States in 2005 and beyond.
Duane Cady--husband, father of five, grandfather of 10, longtime member of his
local Adventist church board, surgeon--is also the highest-ranking physician
in the country.1 On July 1 he becomes the chair of the
Board of Trustees of the American Medical Association, holding the top elected
position in the influential 250,000-member professional organization that helps
to shape health-care services for 300 million Americans.
There is no apparent nervousness about the man, a winsome quality
in a general surgeon for whom steadiness of hand and heart is an indispensable
personal and professional quality. The eyes are calm, the voice is even: an
easy laughter rolls through the stories, policy discussions, and political anecdotes
that fill the hour we spend in front of his great vista.
On a coming Tuesday he will be in Senate Majority Leader Bill
Frist's office, comparing health-care policy notes with a fellow surgeon. An
invitation to the presidential inauguration last January gave him an opportunity
to network with key Representatives and Senators about legislative priorities
for health care in the 109th Congress, including New York Congressman James
Walsh and U.S. Senators Charles Schumer (New York), Charles Grassley (Iowa),
Russ Feingold (Wisconsin), and Hillary Clinton (New York). His weeks are filled
with trips to AMA headquarters in Chicago, or to Philadelphia, New York City,
Washington, D.C.: councils, commissions, policy development sessions and board
meetings proliferate.
A Shared Agenda
"We make no apologies for the fact that the AMA is a membership organization
dedicated to improving the professional lives of thousands of physicians and
their patients across the country," says Cady. "But there's more to
what we're trying to accomplish than usually gets reported in the media. Sometimes
the AMA is pictured in a defensive posture, only watching out for the financial
well-being of physicians.
"But what's good for physicians should ultimately be good
for patients as well," he adds. "This organization's creed since its
founding has focused on the art and science of medicine and the betterment of
public health. For decades now, we've been addressing major public health issues
that affect the health and welfare of millions of Americans."
Cady points to recent AMA initiatives that directly address
important health and lifestyle issues Adventists care about, including obesity,
tobacco industry regulation, alcohol use and abuse, protecting patient safety,
and smoking cessation. In late April the AMA publicly urged the National Collegiate
Athletic Organization (NCAA), the nation's leading regulatory body for collegiate
athletics, to eliminate alcohol advertising associated with NCAA events, including
the NCAA Basketball Tournament, watched by tens of millions of Americans every
March. In so doing, the AMA was supported by a sizable majority of viewers:
an AMA poll found that 62 percent of American adults believe that the NCAA should
not permit advertising by beer companies during collegiate athletic events.
Almost all Adventists would heartily agree.
Cady's colleague and current AMA president John C. Nelson has
courageously addressed what he calls "an ongoing epidemic of alcohol abuse
in this country," noting that 100,000 people in the U.S. die each year
because of untreated alcohol problems. According to Nelson, the economic impact
of alcohol is equally staggering: $185 billion per year is "wasted"
in criminal justice costs, property damage, and lost worker productivity.
The AMA has also lobbied legislators at both the state and federal
level to make certain that antismoking initiatives at the state and county level
actually receive some of the billions of dollars agreed upon in the settlements
of major class-action lawsuits against the tobacco corporations. Cady is particularly
concerned that state governments strapped for new sources of income are using
the antismoking settlement money for unfunded Medicaid mandates, and thus effectively
deflecting the sums from their intended use. That frustrates him as a surgeon,
a taxpayer, and a church member.
"I've had many opportunities to talk privately with colleagues
about my Adventist faith and lifestyle," says Cady. "Sometimes I get
asked directly what my faith brings to a particular policy discussion. More
often, the informal or social time that AMA trustees and officers spend with
each other helps us understand each other better.
"I've also discovered that there is a lot of respect among
my colleagues for Adventist medical education, particularly at Loma Linda University,"
Cady continues, smiling because he has managed to work the name of the medical
school from which he graduated into a response. "I'm actually one of two
Adventist physicians on the AMA Board of Trustees who graduated from Loma Linda.
(Rebecca Patchin, an anesthesiologist from Riverside, California, holds another
of the 19 elected positions on the governing body of the organization).
"People certainly know who we are and what Adventist beliefs
are," he says with conviction. "I'm pleased that we're known as serious,
credible people in the medical profession. In my opinion, that brings honor
to both the Lord and His people."
The Adventist Church's Health Ministries Department agrees.
"The church is blessed by the outreach of physicians like Dr. Cady and
Dr. Patchin," notes Dr. Peter Landless, associate director. "They
are representative of so many dedicated physicians who influence the practice
of medicine and touch the lives of countless patients. The effort of professionals
like these continues the Christian imperative of teaching and healing in the
blended ministry."
Inside the AMA
The organization that Duane Cady heads is the oldest and most influential professional
medical organization in the United States. Founded in 1847, the American Medical
Association first sought to standardize medical education in the young nation,
which, as Cady notes, was then a "disaster." Persons with as little
as six months' clinical training could be licensed as medical doctors, and standards
of care differed dramatically between wealthy urban centers and rural farm communities.
As professional standards for family practice, surgery, and
a wide variety of professional specialties became established through the decades,
the organization turned increasingly to address public health concerns. Drawn
from an active federation of county, state, and national medical societies in
which member physicians are involved, delegates craft policies and medical standards
in a 535-member AMA House of Delegates designed to mirror the combined Senate
and House representation of the U.S. Congress. A president is elected to a three-year
term--one each as president-elect, president, and past-president. The Speaker
of the AMA House of Delegates is elected to a four-year term. They work in tandem
with the 21-member Board of Trustees that Cady will chair as of July 1, 2005.
Other important structures within the AMA include five House
of Delegates councils that advise the organization about ethical and judicial
affairs, long-range planning and development, medical education, medical service,
and scientific affairs. Participation or leadership in one of the councils is
frequently a precursor to larger duties with the national organization: Cady
himself served on the Council on Medical Service, and in that role helped to
develop AMA positions on Medicare and Medicaid programs, health insurance coverage,
physician reimbursement, and managed care. He is also a past president of the
AMA Foundation, the major fund-raising arm of the organization.
Cady joined the local medical society in the Syracuse, New York,
region shortly after he began his surgery practice in 1966, and worked on a
variety of regional and state projects, including emergency preparedness, for
which he received specialized training from the U.S. military. After nearly
30 years of involvement with organized medicine, he was elected president of
the New York State society, and later became a delegate to the AMA House of
Delegates. Following a short tenure in the deliberative group, he stood for
election as a trustee in 1999, and joined the AMA Board that year.
Reelected in 2003 to a second four-year term in July 2004, Cady
was voted chair-elect of the Board, and designated to assume the one-year chairmanship
this summer. When his term on the Board of Trustees expires in 2007, the doctor
says that he will retire from organized medicine after a career spanning more
than 40 years.
All in the Professional Family
Some of those who may be quietly looking forward to Duane Cady's slower pace
of life in retirement include the members of his own family, most of whom understand
the pressures of organized medicine because of their chosen professions.
Joyce (Clarke) Cady, Duane's wife of more than 40 years, trained
and worked as an elementary school teacher for more than 15 years, completing
her career as principal of Parkview Junior Academy in Syracuse. The eldest of
their five children, Jann, earned R.N. and M.B.A. degrees, and is vice president
for nursing at Hinsdale Hospital just west of Chicago. Mark, M.D., is an anesthesiologist
who practices in Syracuse and serves as a teacher in the adult Sabbath school
of the Westvale Adventist Church.
Another daughter, Beth, also an M.D., is an otolaryngologist
(ear-nose-throat specialist) in Syracuse. Active in area musical groups, she
serves as a member of the Executive Committee of the New York Conference. David,
the only one of their sons to not live in the central New York region, holds
an M.B.A. and is sales manager at a commercial printing firm in Clinton, Massachusetts,
where he and his wife are much involved in community and church musical events.
The Cadys' youngest son, Jeff, earned a bachelor of science and is an underwriter
for the Medical Liability Insurance Company, a Syracuse-based company that insures
nearly 40,000 physicians and 370 hospitals in New York, Ohio, and New Jersey.
Ten grandchildren (six girls, four boys) also look forward to
the day when Grandpa's life slows down at least a bit. By their reckoning, that
should include ample time for guided horseback rides around the pasture, walks
in the nearby summer woods, and lots of laughter.
Home Advantage
Not many professionals who rise to Duane Cady's level of skill and office are
fortunate enough to live near the hills of home. The new chair of the AMA Board
of Trustees, however, lives only slightly more than an hour from his birthplace
in Endicott, New York, a town of 13,000 just west of Binghamton in upstate New
York's "Southern Tier" mountain chain. Educated in a local public
elementary school, Cady attended nearby Union-Endicott High School through his
junior year, but then transferred to South Lancaster Academy, then an Adventist
boarding school in central Massachusetts.2
After graduation from SLA, Cady went on to attend Atlantic Union
College in the same town, graduating in 1955 with a major in chemistry. His
senior yearbook reveals a lifelong ability for bringing order and discipline
to sometimes unwieldy organizations: he served as sergeant at arms of his junior
and senior classes, and of the college's Student Association. (See the graphic
on page 10). A four-year member of the college band, he also sold advertising
for the Lancastrian, the college newspaper, and headed up the Foreign
Missions Band during his last year.
Married shortly after his college graduation, Duane enrolled
in the College of Medical Evangelists (now Loma Linda University) in 1955. He
graduated from CME/LLU in 1959, and returned to central New York to complete
his residency at the Upstate Medical Center in Syracuse.
In 1964 Duane began a two-year tour of duty in the U.S. Army,
spending one year in Vietnam as an army surgeon and captain of the U.S. Army
Medical Corps. Stationed at U.S. bases in Bien Hoa and Saigon, his work included
triage, general and vascular surgery on the wounded, emergency medicine--and
just about anything else that needed doing. He also worked with his Loma Linda
classmate, Dr. Doug Thoreson, medical missionary at Saigon Adventist Hospital.
When he came home in 1966, Duane joined the surgical faculty
at SUNY, Upstate Medical University, where he worked as a clinical associate
professor of surgery. Two years later he joined the department of surgery at
St. Joseph's Hospital in downtown Syracuse, and went on to serve as chair of
the department, president of the hospital's medical staff, and even a member
of the hospital's Board of Trustees. Along the way, he joined relevant professional
and licensing organizations, including the American College of Surgeons, the
American Society of General Surgeons, and the Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Medical
Society. He was subsequently appointed by New York state governor George Pataki
as chair of the New York State Medicaid Manage Care Advisory Council, and also
served on the governor's Task Force on Hospital Reimbursement Reform.
Cady's local congregation, the Syracuse (now Westvale) Adventist
Church, also benefited from his medical and business skills. He teamed with
several pastors in presenting smoking-cessation programs in the community, served
on the church board and finance committee, and as chairman of the Parkview Junior
Academy Board for 10 years. As his children grew up through Adventist elementary
schools, academies, and colleges, Duane helped to shape the quality of education
they received by serving on the New York Conference K-12 Education Committee.
In April of this year Cady joined members of his 50-year class
at his alma mater, Atlantic Union College, where he serves on the school's Board
of Trustees. Cady's skill as a leader and businessman has been tapped yet again,
as he has agreed to head the college's $25-million capital campaign, which will
be launched this autumn.
The Big Picture
As the shadows stretch up Meeker Hill and the sun disappears in the direction
of Buffalo, Dr. Cady returns again to the vista he spends most of his waking
hours thinking about.
"Many Americans are beginning to discover that they have
a very real stake in things the AMA cares very much about," Cady notes.
"Physicians and politicians have a lot to say about medical liability reform
these days because it's becoming a crucial issue of patient access to health
care. Most Americans discover the issue only when they can't get the medical
or health services they need.
"When the obstetricians leave an area because they can
no longer afford $175,000 in liability insurance premiums, or neurosurgeons
leave because they're continually being sued for astronomical sums, medical
care in that region or state suffers. Just to illustrate: by the latest count,
a third of the counties in New York State--21 out of 62--don't have obstetricians
residing in them anymore."
Cady also points out that access to health care is restricted
when Medicare reimbursement to physicians from the government continues to drop--and
it's projected to go down 33 percent in the next five years. "Fewer and
fewer doctors can afford to treat those who most have a rightful claim on tax-funded
health care," he notes.
"One of the AMA's biggest initiatives at the moment is
to try to devise a plan to help the uninsured in America," Cady adds. "America
has a good health-care delivery system, but we still have to deal with the fact
that there are 45 million people here without any health insurance, 85 percent
of whom are working. Should a system be devised in which, like car insurance,
health insurance is mandatory for individuals, or should we continue to depend
on the traditional mandate that employers provide it? It seems to make sense
to devise a program in which the insurance belongs to the individual--a portable
plan--that can be taken from place to place as persons move or change jobs."
"Health care matters most when you or someone you love
really needs it," Cady concludes, "and it's my mission in life. I
don't get to preach sermons or hold evangelistic meetings. But if I can help
to make certain that there is a competent doctor available when that phone rings
in the middle of the night, and a reasonable way to pay for his or her services,
I think I'll have done something useful to serve my world and my church."
_________________________
1 Ranking physicians is a subjective enterprise: Cady's rank
as nation's top physician is supported by the fact of his election to the AMA's
highest post by physicians themselves. Other candidates for "top doctor"
include the surgeon general of the United States, a presidential appointee.
2 South Lancaster became a day academy (no boarding students) in 1965 when a
new boarding school, Pioneer Valley Academy, opened in New Braintree, Massachusetts.
_________________________
Bill Knott is an associate editor of the Adventist Review.